Family history brick wall: who was Luke O’Grady?

Posted on March 3rd, 2014 by Paul Stainthorp

One of my great-grandfathers was Frank Corr a.k.a. Frank O’Grady (1888-1962) of Birmingham and Sheffield. I’m trying to confirm the origins and discover the fate of his biological father Luke O’Grady, my great-great-grandfather. What follows is an outline of the life of Frank O’Grady Corr, notes on the identity of Luke O’Grady, and my ideas for further research.

Paul Harland Stainthorp (paul@paulstainthorp.com). Version 1.7.0, updated 10th November 2014.

  1. The life of Frank O’Grady Corr
  2. Who was Luke O’Grady?
  3. Where next? Ideas for further research
  4. References
  5. Note on links to sources

The life of Frank O’Grady Corr

Back yard, Court 15, Inge Street, Birmingham

Back yard, Court 15, Inge Street, Birmingham
A rare preserved example of the thousands of back-to-back courts that used to provide housing for workers and their families in the years of the 19th and 20th centuries.
© Copyright Brian Robert Marshall and licensed for reuse under this Creative Commons Licence

Frank was born on Sunday, 22nd January 1888, at the back of 135 Brearley Street in the Lozells area of Birmingham.1

His mother was Emily née Farley, born 1854,2 the widow of Edward Corr, a turner & fitter from Wolverhampton.3 Edward’s parents were Felix Corr and Harriet née Spooner.4,5

Emily and Edward married on 14th July 1872.6 They had seven children together: John Felix (1873-1956), Florence (1876-77), Beatrice (1876-77), Alfred Edward (1877-1900), Emmett (1880-81), Edward (1883-1933), and Harold (1885-1952).7 Three children died in infancy. In 1881 the family lived on Burbury Street, Lozells.3

Edward Corr died in 1887, more than ten months before my great-grandfather’s birth.8

The informant on Frank’s birth certificate was his father Luke O’Grady. Luke gave his occupation as glass embosser (journeyman)1—a skilled trade connected to the glassmaking industry common in the English Black Country since the 17th century9—and his address as 135 Brearley Street where Frank was born. Frank’s mother is named as Emily O’Grady (sic) formerly Farley.1

This use of the surname O’Grady for or by Emily must have been a common-law arrangement, or else a polite fiction on behalf of Luke O’Grady for the registrar’s benefit: there is no record of a marriage between Emily and anyone named O’Grady, and Emily never used the name again.

It seems that Emily could not read or write;6 perhaps that’s why she didn’t register the birth herself.

In the 1891 census, Emily and Luke’s three-year-old son Frank O’Grady was with his maternal grandmother Emma Farley in Barr Street, Birmingham;10 Emily Corr was a few streets away at 6 Tower Street working as a machinist, with John, Alfred and Edward, three of her four surviving sons by Edward Corr.11 (The fourth son, Harold, was also being cared for by relatives locally.12) Frank’s father Luke O’Grady is nowhere to be found.

After this point my great-grandfather Frank used Corr exclusively as his adult surname.

Blaco Road, Attercliffe, Sheffield

Blaco Road, Attercliffe, Sheffield
Blaco Road looking towards the gates of Carbrook Park, showing No. 5. 25th April 1966. Photographer: H. Ainscough.
Found on the Picture Sheffield website
© Copyright David Ainscough – used with permission

By 1901, Frank Corr had left Birmingham and moved to Sheffield with his mother and half-brother Harold, and was working as a labourer in the steel industry at the age of just thirteen.13 Emily, Harold and Frank lived at 46 Blaco Road, Attercliffe-cum-Darnall, along with ‘boarder’ Charles Tillbrook and two of Charles’s children. Emily Corr née Farley married her ‘boarder’ later the same year and became Emily Tillbrook.14

(In 1911, Frank’s mother Emily and her second husband Charles Tillbrook were living at 83 Clifton Street, Sheffield, with Charles’s daughter Elizabeth and Emily’s son Harold Corr – albeit recorded on the census under his stepfather’s surname as “Harold Tillbrook”.15 Emily died in 1919;16 Charles Tillbrook in 1930.17 Of Frank’s three surviving half-brothers, John Felix stayed in Birmingham and became a brassworker.18 Edward joined the Army and was stationed at Whittington Barracks near Lichfield in Staffs:19 he served with the 3rd South Staffordshire Regiment in WWI.20 Harold Corr/”Tillbrook” settled in Sheffield and worked as a gas stoker in the steel industry.15)

Photograph of Frank Corr

Frank Corr
Taken at a family wedding in 1946.
From a family photograph, © all rights reserved

Frank stayed in Sheffield for the rest of his life, marrying Lily Bowden on 16th February 1907 at Sheffield Registry Office. To the registrar he gave his father’s name as Luke O’Grady, occupation glass embosser. Frank’s marriage certificate included both names for the record (“Frank O’Grady otherwise Frank Corr“) – this is the last recorded use of the name O’Grady.21 By 1911, Lily and Frank Corr—occupation steel dresser—were living in Carbrook, Sheffield with their first two daughters of an eventual eleven children.22

I have been told by a distant cousin that Frank and Lily’s eldest daughter Emily (born 1907)23 certainly knew of something relating to her father being of Irish decent and that he was probably illegitimate.24

Frank Corr died on 19th January 1962 and was buried with his wife Lily in Tinsley Park Cemetery in Sheffield.25 He didn’t leave a will.

Frank and Lily’s seventh child was my maternal grandfather Harold Corr (1921-1999).26,27 A career soldier, Harold served in WWII, Korea, Hong Kong and Germany before leaving the Army and settling in Lincolnshire in the 1960s. Harold Corr and my grandmother Ruby née Howson had six children and fifteen grandchildren including the author of this document.

Who was Luke O’Grady?

“Wolverhampton Luke”

I now believe that Frank’s father was almost certainly Luke Grady, born 1867 in Wolverhampton.28

Luke was the son of Irish-born cordwainer (i.e. master shoe/bootmaker) William Grady, of Armagh, and Wolverhampton native Jane née Spooner, who married at St George’s church in Wolverhampton on 23rd April 1859.29 Luke Grady had four sisters: Ellen or Helen (born 1860), Martha (1864), Agnes (1871) and Winifred (1876), plus one older brother Mark (1862).7 They lived at 80 Temple Street, Wolverhampton.30

“Wolverhampton Luke” Grady was the first cousin of Edward Corr, the dead husband of Emily Corr née Farley. Their respective mothers (Harriet and Jane Spooner) were sisters, the daughters of shoemaker Edward Spooner and Ann née Highfield.31

Sketch family tree showing the relationship between Edward Corr and Luke O’Grady

Sketch family tree showing the relationship between Edward Corr and Luke O’Grady
Some dates of birth and death are unconfirmed
Image created using Family Echo software (www.familyecho.com)

The patronymic “O'” in Irish surnames was often dropped in the 19th century, at least in England, so “Grady” and “O’Grady” would have been almost interchangeable. The Wolverhampton family appear as plain “Grady” in almost all registration/census records and in an 1880 newspaper report concerning a court case,32 although Luke’s father was recorded as “William O. Grady” on one census.33

Jane Grady died in 1878 and William in 1884,34,35 so Luke was pretty much alone in the world by the time of Frank O’Grady’s birth in 1888.

There isn’t a single record of “Wolverhampton Luke” Grady in England after 1881: no marriage or death entries and no census or employment records. His proximity and family ties to the Corrs, along with the suspicious timing of his disappearance, all suggest strongly that he is Frank’s father. However I have no positive evidence to connect him with the Black Country glass industry or to place him in Birmingham in 1888. I’ve also been unable to trace the fate of all of Luke’s siblings – what happened to them all after they lost their father in 1884?

(Luke’s brother Mark [O']Grady seems to have become a general clerk for the Great Western Railway in London & Cardiff.36 He died in 1889 in Newport, Monmouthshire, Wales. His youngest sister Winifred married Austin Horsley in 1897, had one daughter, and died in Sussex in 1930. Agnes is recorded working as a domestic servant in London in 1891, but then disappears. Of Ellen and Martha, nothing.)7

“Buffalo Bill Luke”

I am not the only person searching for Luke O’Grady. I have been contacted by a descendant of Francis Patrick O’Grady (c.1893-1971): Francis’s father was also called Luke O’Grady, and seems also to have disappeared somewhat mysteriously.37

Francis P. O’Grady was born c. 1st March 1893, possibly in Ireland, although no birth or baptism records have been traced for him. When he married in England in 1925, and again (having been widowed) in 1930, he gave his father’s name as Luke O’Grady, occupation ‘house decorator’.37

According to a family story, Francis’s father Luke O’Grady left his wife Mary Ann [maiden name unknown] and their young son, to travel with Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show, and may have had one or more children with another woman. Francis P. O’Grady apparently grew up in Ireland and England, had an adopted / step-sister called Mona, and a cousin (either paternal or maternal) named Sammy. When Francis’s mother Mary Ann O’Grady died in 1940 she was recorded as being the widow of Luke O’Grady, house decorator (master).37

It is possible that the same Luke O’Grady was the father of both Frank O’Grady Corr and Francis Patrick O’Grady, making them half-brothers. Even if this is not the case, “Buffalo Bill” Luke O’Grady seems to have been just as elusive—both before and after the birth of his son—as ‘my’ Luke O’Grady.

“Holbeach Luke” (Now discounted.)

There was one other Luke Grady alive in England at the time of Frank’s birth (Luke Grady b.1848 in Holbeach, Lincolnshire – d.1891 in Cockermouth, Cumberland)38,39 but “Holbeach Luke” raised a family in northern England and doesn’t seem to have had any connection to Birmingham or to glassmaking.40

Germanic Luke”

The Germanic, before 1895

The Germanic, before 1895
White Star Line steamship, built 1874 at Belfast by Harland and Wolff, as she appeared before her funnels were lengthened and an extra deck added in 1895.
Courtesy of the Norway Heritage Collection – www.norwayheritage.com
Source: www.heritage-ships.com

On 10th August 1888, eight months after Frank was born, the ship the Germanic docked at New York, late of Liverpool and Queenstown (Cobh). On board was Luke O’Grady, a labourer, aged 35, nationality English. The age and occupation are wrong for “Wolverhampton Luke”, but the timing is suspicious!41

On 20th July 1894 at the Common Pleas Court in New York, Luke became a naturalized American. His address at the time was 419 East 22nd Street, New York City and his sponsor was Timothy Maloney.42

I have been unable to trace “Germanic Luke” O’Grady in England before 1888 or in the USA after naturalization in 1894. He does not appear in any of the US censuses as far as I can tell.

So: did Luke Grady of Wolverhampton emigrate immediately after his son’s birth in 1888? Was he the father of Francis P. O’Grady as well as Frank O’Grady Corr? Or were these Luke [O']Gradys two or three different people (in which case: what happened to them all, and to “Wolverhampton” Luke’s remaining siblings?).

Finally, there is the possibility that Luke O’Grady was simply a stock pseudonym used by whomever registered the birth, and that Frank’s real father’s name was something else entirely. (Now discounted.)

Where next? Ideas for further research

These are my ideas for further research to prove the identity, origin and fate of my 2-greats-grandfather:

  • Track down more records from Frank’s own life – there is at least one other descendant of Frank Corr who is researching the family history.
  • Buy birth, marriage and death records as needed for Emily Farley, Edward Corr, Emma Farley, Charles Tillbrook and all of Frank’s half-siblings (est. cost: £150+).
  • Buy copies of “Wolverhampton Luke” Grady’s birth certificate and his parents’ marriage & death certificates (est. cost: £37).
  • Try and determine the fate of “Wolverhampton Luke” Grady’s brother and four sisters.
  • Search the UK censuses for glass embossers in 1891, in the possibility that Luke O’Grady changed his name but continued in the same occupation.
  • Find out who lived at 2 Back 135 Brearley Street, Lozells, Birmingham, immediately before and after Frank’s birth in 1888.
  • Determine the whereabouts of “Holbeach Luke” Grady in 1888, if only to rule him out.
  • Share all information with anyone who is researching the identity of Luke the father of Francis Patrick O’Grady; in particular for possible records of Luke O’Grady living with a wife Mary Ann in Ireland, and/or as an employee of Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show in the early 1900s.
  • Trace any living descendants of Emily Farley’s children Frank Corr, John Felix Corr, Alfred Edward Corr, Edward Corr jr and Harold Corr, and those of William Grady of Wolverhampton.
  • Look for records of Luke [O']Grady in Ireland and Scotland both before and after 1888.
  • Investigate Y-chromosomal DNA testing between a living male-line descendant of Frank Corr (there are four in my immediate family) vs. a proven patrilineal descendant of William Grady if one can be found.
  • Contact local family history societies in the Black Country/Birmingham area (e.g. the Birmingham and Midland Society for Genealogy); also surname special interest groups for Grady/O’Grady.
  • Visit the Birmingham ArchivesBlack Country Museum, and Broadfield House Glass Museum in Stourbridge, specifically to look for documents from the Black Country glassmaking industry – are there apprenticeship records for Luke O’Grady or is he otherwise mentioned?
  • Visit New York to try and find out what happened to “Germanic Luke” [O']Grady who became an American citizen in 1894.
  • Look for evidence of emigration other than to New York in 1888: not necessarily to the USA.

References

  1. General Register Office. Certified copy of an entry of birth. Entry for Frank O’Grady, 22nd January 1888. Copy in the possession of Paul Harland Stainthorp (paul@paulstainthorp.com). GRO index reference: Birmingham 6d 132. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=PA65u5keSBZ%2BFKido5GqNA&scan=1 (accessed 23rd September 2014).
  2. General Register Office. Index to the register of births. Entry for Emily Farley, June Quarter 1854. GRO index reference: Birmingham 6d 213. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=330lIBf34uMdnjR%2FG4u04Q&scan=1 (accessed 23rd September 2014).
  3. General Register Office. 1881 census returns. Archive reference RG11, piece 2997, folio 77, page 50. Entry for 6 Court 1 House, Burbury Street, Birmingham. Transcription. FamilySearch. https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/X3TS-VGQ (accessed 24th September 2014).
  4. Parish of Wolverhampton St Peter. Parish register. Entry for the marriage of Felix Corr and Harriet Spooner, 12th December 1852.
  5. Parish of Wolverhampton St Mary. Parish register. Entry for the baptism of Edward Corr, 24th July 1853.
  6. Ancestry Library Editionhttp://interactive.ancestrylibrary.com/4994/40458_316659-00101/ (accessed 24th September 2014).
  7. General Register Office. GRO index references [various]. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/ (accessed 3rd March 2014).
  8. General Register Office. Index to the register of deaths. Entry for Edward Corr, March Quarter 1887. GRO index reference: Birmingham 6d 83. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=LRWp3lqiFmdZVqXQrkColQ&scan=1 (accessed 24th September 2014).
  9. BBC Online. ‘About the Black Country – Glass.’ Where I Live – the Black Country. 2005. http://www.bbc.co.uk/blackcountry/uncovered/glass.shtml (accessed 24th September 2014).
  10. General Register Office. 1891 census returns. Archive reference RG12, piece 2386, folio 50, page 24. Entry for 1 Court 15, Barr Street, Birmingham.
  11. General Register Office. 1891 census returns. Archive reference RG12, piece 2387, folio 102, page 45. Entry for 6, Tower Street, Birmingham.
  12. General Register Office. 1891 census returns. Archive reference RG12, piece 2416, folio 45, pages 20-21. Entry for Court 2 x 4 Cardigan Street, Birmingham.
  13. General Register Office. 1901 census returns. Archive reference RG13, piece 4387, folio 143, page 3. Entry for 52, Blaco Road, Attercliffe cum Darnall, Sheffield.
  14. General Register Office. Index to the register of marriages. Entry for Emily Corr, June Quarter 1901. GRO index reference: Sheffield 9c 795. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=rK0yNCBcQoqXtsSZc1hNtw&scan=1 (accessed 24th September 2014).
  15. General Register Office. 1911 census returns. Census reference: RG14PN27994 RG78PN1600 RD510 SD7 ED6 SN340. Entry for 83, Clifton Street, Sheffield.
  16. Sheffield & District Family History Society. National Burials Index. Entry for Emily Tillbrook, Sheffield Municipal Cemetery, 23rd June 1919. Sheffield: S&DFHS.
  17. Sheffield & District Family History Society. National Burials Index. Entry for Charles Tillbrook, Sheffield Municipal Cemetery, 19th July 1930.
  18. General Register Office. 1911 census returns. Census reference: RG14PN18285 RG78PN1102 RD385 SD4 ED16 SN93. Entry for 5 Gerrard Street, Lozells, Aston.
  19. General Register Office. 1911 census returns. Census reference: RG14PN16889 RD367 SD1 ED32 SN1. Entry for Whittington Barracks, Lichfield, Staffordshire.
  20. War Office. Medal card of Corr, Edward; Corps: South Staffordshire Regiment; Regiment No: 6118. Archive reference: WO 372/5/31373. Kew: The National Archives. http://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/D1953743 (accessed 24th September 2014).
  21. General Register Office. Certified copy of an entry of marriage. Entry for Frank Corr and Lily Bowden, 16th February 1907. Copy in the possession of Paul Harland Stainthorp (paul@paulstainthorp.com). GRO index reference: Sheffield 9c 754. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=4UpNF1qg%2FRJ101VnPcGBRQ&scan=1 (accessed 24th September 2014).
  22. General Register Office. 1911 census returns. Census reference: RG14PN27994 RG78PN1600 RD510 SD7 ED6 SN338. Entry for 87, Surbiton Street, Sheffield.
  23. General Register Office. Index to the register of births. Entry for Emily Corr, June Quarter 1907. GRO index reference: Sheffield 9c 725. FreeBMDhttp://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=YCwsAh1GgpKpnJfth5LXKA&scan=1 (accessed 24th September 2014).
  24. Sterling, J. Re: Corr family. Email to Paul Harland Stainthorp (paul@paulstainthorp.com), 27th March 2014.
  25. Headstone of Frank and Lily Corr. Tinsley Park Cemetery, Sheffield.
  26. General Register Office. Certified copy of an entry of birth. Entry for Harold Corr, 5th June 1921. Copy in the possession of Paul Harland Stainthorp (paul@paulstainthorp.com). GRO index reference: Sheffield 9c 1351. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=9K5KcX6BYsofroh9Ags%2FLg&scan=1 (accessed 24th September 2014).
  27. General Register Office. Certified copy of an entry of death. Entry for Harold Corr, 18th November 1999. Copy in the possession of Paul Harland Stainthorp (paul@paulstainthorp.com).
  28. General Register Office. Index to the register of births. Entry for Luke Grady, December Quarter 1867. GRO index reference: Wolverhampton 6b 414. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=KdJn8qIyl77vFdCsfFBR%2BQ&scan=1 (accessed 7th November 2014).
  29. Parish of Wolverhampton St George. Parish register. Entry for the marriage of William Grady and Jane Spooner, 23rd April 1859. Transcription. Black Country History. http://blackcountryhistory.org/collections/getrecord/GB149_PRI_48_SU1/ (accessed 7th November 2014).
  30. General Register Office. 1871 census returns. Archive reference RG10, piece 2930, folio 113, page 21. Entry for Temple Street, Wolverhampton.
  31. Szimeth, J. Re: Luke O’Grady. Email to Paul Harland Stainthorp (paul@paulstainthorp.com), 6th November 2014.
  32. ‘The Wolverhampton seduction case.’ The Birmingham Daily Post. 20th July 1880. Page 5. 19th Century British Newspapers. http://find.galegroup.com/bncn/ (accessed 7th November 2014).
  33. General Register Office. 1881 census returns. Archive reference RG11, piece 2793, folio 31, page 25. Entry for 80 Temple Street, Wolverhampton. Transcription. FamilySearch. https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/X3VS-CGP (accessed 7th November 2014).
  34. General Register Office. Index to the register of deaths. Entry for Jane Grady, December Quarter 1878. GRO index reference: Wolverhampton 6b 354. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=JPbbG3m5XZTT0rjGotUzcw&scan=1 (accessed 7th November 2014).
  35. General Register Office. Index to the register of deaths. Entry for William Grady, June Quarter 1884. GRO index reference: Wolverhampton 6b 325. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=iqF6STi46h%2BmKWYfQC0uYw&scan=1 (accessed 7th November 2014).
  36. Great Western Railway Company. Staff Records. Archive reference: RAIL 264, 1835-1962. Kew: The National Archives. http://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C12452 (accessed 9th November 2014).
  37. Milne, S. Re: The mysterious Luke O’Grady. Email to Paul Harland Stainthorp (paul@paulstainthorp.com), 9th August 2014.
  38. General Register Office. Index to the register of births. Entry for Luke Grady, December Quarter 1848. GRO index reference: Holbeach XIV 397. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=niCuL6o9nOulxieoxUw1%2Fw&scan=1 (accessed 10th November 2014).
  39. General Register Office. Index to the register of deaths. Entry for Luke Grady, December Quarter 1891. GRO index reference: Cockermouth 10b 442. FreeBMD. http://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/information.pl?cite=YtDAHHUApCUyiuyG2IEe6A&scan=1 (accessed 10th November 2014).
  40. General Register Office. 1881 census returns. Archive reference RG11, piece 3444, folio 80, page 7. Entry for Hill Top, Dronfield, Chesterfield, Derbyshire. Transcription. FamilySearch. https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:XQSQ-MBH (accessed 10th November 2014).
  41. United States Customs Service. Passenger list of the Germanic arriving at New York, 10th August 1888. Washington, DC: The National Archives at Washington. Ancestry Library Edition. http://interactive.ancestrylibrary.com/7488/NYM237_523-0871/ (accessed 10th November 2014).
  42. New York Common Pleas Court. Petition for naturalization, 20th July 1894. Bundle 768, record 86. New York, NY: The National Archives at New York City. Ancestry Library Edition. http://interactive.ancestrylibrary.com/1629/31194_120936-01117/ (accessed 10th November 2014).

Note on links to sources

Hyperlinks in the text of this document point to source documents and catalogues/indexes which contain or illustrate the information referenced. Where possible I have linked to free & open sources (FreeBMD; catalogue/archival records). In other cases where the source is not freely available, I have linked to a record within Ancestry Library Edition: these links will display an error message unless you first establish a session on Ancestry within a subscribing library building (e.g. in Lincolnshire).

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

One Response to “Family history brick wall: who was Luke O’Grady?”

  1. Ray Wilson says:

    Fascinating work, Paul. Good luck with the search!

Leave a Reply